Countries meeting at a United Nations conference in Geneva agreed on Saturday, 21 November, to spend the next two years working on an international instrument to govern lethal autonomous weapons systems, often called "killer robots". Campaigners, however, said the outcome fell well short of the legally binding rules they had sought.
The 128 states party to the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) reached the agreement at the end of a week-long review conference, after negotiations ran through the night and finished in the early hours of Saturday. Because decisions under the convention require consensus, every member had to accept the final wording.
Lethal autonomous weapons are systems that can select and attack targets without a human making the final decision. Reuters reported that around 100 countries backed a push for binding rules within a short timeframe, but it was resisted by leading weapons-producing states such as the United States, Russia and Israel. According to diplomats, procedural objections raised by Russia forced the cancellation of some formal sessions.
Conference chair Julien Thoeni, a Swiss diplomat, told reporters that some countries had rejected the word "negotiate", so the final text speaks of the "elaboration" of an instrument instead. The coming work, he said, should establish which weapons international humanitarian law would prohibit and which could be allowed under regulation, and that states would later decide whether the result should be a treaty and how binding it should be. He described the outcome as a significant step, saying it showed multilateral diplomacy could still deliver results.
UN disarmament chief Izumi Nakamitsu said completing an instrument in two years was a "very compressed timeframe", but stressed that the path to a legally binding agreement remained open, AFP reported.
Rights groups were critical. The Stop Killer Robots coalition, which represents more than 300 organisations, said states had adopted a "watered-down mandate" without a clear route to a binding instrument. Verity Coyle of Human Rights Watch said the result "does not provide the urgent action needed to agree new rules – but the technology is racing ahead".
Reuters noted that the talks were held amid rising concern about autonomous weapons being used in wars such as those in Ukraine and Sudan and in the Middle East. Calls for firm, legally binding rules have come from the UN secretary-general, the Pope and the Red Cross.
Source: Al Jazeera, Reuters (via Business Recorder), AFP
File photo: the Palais des Nations, United Nations Office at Geneva. Photo: Vassil via Wikimedia Commons, CC0 (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/deed.en). Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Palace_of_Nations_Geneva_20102014_02.jpg